Search:
The Brattle Group
About Brattle Areas of Expertise Experts Publications News & Events Careers Contact Us
cambridge sanfran washington london madrid rome`

Demand Response, Energy Efficiency, and the Smart Grid

Utilities, regulatory agencies, and independent system operators (ISOs) have begun to explore and implement innovative methods for managing demand as a means to lower power costs to consumers, improve system reliability, meet environmental standards, and ensure resource adequacy. As part of these efforts, power companies have announced initiatives and partnerships that will lay the groundwork for their involvement in the development of the smart grid.

The smart grid encompasses virtually all facets of the electric industry, with benefits ranging from expanded generation resource alternatives to decreased energy consumption. At the leading edge of these initiatives is a new crop of customer-focused programs that use technology and dynamic pricing signals to manage customer demand during critical time periods. Specifically, several critical peak pricing pilot programs are taking place in a handful of states around the U.S. and Canada. These pilots test several design elements including: customer response to different pricing levels, frequencies, and durations; customer acceptance of a critical peak price versus a critical peak rebate; whether to employ an opt-in or opt-out deployment strategy; and the role of different enabling technologies. The Brattle Group has assisted utilities in designing, evaluating, and implementing various customer-side smart grid initiatives.

Since most smart grid plans begin with the deployment of smart meters, it is often necessary to perform a cost benefit analysis to assess whether the capital costs associated with meter deployment will be offset by operational benefits and demand response (DR). We are an industry leader in addressing opportunities and market barriers associated with DR. We design and evaluate programs to reduce peak loads and develop energy efficiency (EE) programs to lower customer bills and protect the environment. In addition to the load, reliability, energy, and environmental benefits, well-designed programs can improve customer satisfaction, an important regulatory benchmark for judging the success of utility operations. We also assist clients with the evaluation of implemented DR programs, which requires an accurate assessment of baseline customer behavior absent the DR program. We understand how to construct the necessary “but for” scenarios, and provide reliable forecasting methods and energy economic consulting expertise in benefit-cost analysis.

Furthermore, traditional load management programs, such as direct load control, are being integrated with dynamic pricing programs. These retail-market programs are complemented by incentive-based wholesale market programs including load curtailment, demand bidding, emergency demand response, capacity market programs, and ancillary service programs. Our economic consultants evaluate such programs.

Representative Engagements

View All

See Also

 
 

Related Experts


Principals:
Judy Chang
Ahmad Faruqui
Peter S. Fox-Penner
Philip Q Hanser
Dean M. Murphy
Samuel A. Newell
Jürgen Weiss
Joseph B. Wharton


Academic Advisors:
David Robinson


Senior Associates:
Ryan Hledik
Sanem Sergici

Selected Publications

An Assessment of PGE’s Demand Response Potential
The Slowdown in Sales Growth and the Prospects for Transmission
Get Ready for Much Spikier Energy Prices: The Under-Appreciated Market Impacts of Displacing Generation with Demand Response
Consistency of Results in Dynamic Pricing Experiments – Toward a Meta Analysis
The Future of Rate Design In California
Demand Growth and the New Normal
Theory and Practice of Cost-Reflective Rates
Implementation of Dynamic Pricing: Trends and Debates
Direct Load Control of Residential Air Conditioners in Texas
Managing the Benefits and Costs of Dynamic Pricing in Australia
Shaping Our Energy Future through Dynamic Pricing
The Future of Demand Growth: How five forces are creating a new normal
Architecting the Future of Dynamic Pricing
California’s Search for a Better Rate Design
Time-Varying and Dynamic Rate Design (external link)
The Transition to Dynamic Pricing
Dynamic Pricing of Electricity for Residential Customers: The Evidence from Michigan (external link)
The Current State of U.S. Demand Response
Dynamic Pricing for Residential and Small C&I Customers
Dynamic Pricing in a Moderate Climate: The Evidence from Connecticut (external link)
The Discovery of Price Responsiveness – A Survey of Experiments Involving Dynamic Pricing of Electricity (external link)
Smart Pricing & Smart Charging
California’s Search for a Better Rate Design
Energy Efficiency and Demand Response in 2020 – A Survey of Expert Opinion (external link)
The Rediscovery of Demand-Side Management
The Rediscovery of Demand-Side Management
Green Ovations: Innovations in Green Technologies
U.S. Regulatory Mechanisms For Promoting Energy Efficiency
Energy Efficiency and Demand Response in 2020 - A Survey of Expert Opinion
Smart Pricing, Smart Charging
Dynamic Pricing of Electricity and its Discontents
The Energy Efficiency Imperative
The Tao of The Smart Grid
Dynamic Pricing of Electricity in the Mid-Atlantic Region: Econometric Results from the Baltimore Gas and Electric Company Experiment
Will Smart Prices Induce Smart Charging of Electric Vehicles?
The Costs and Benefits of Smart Meters for Residential Customers
Energy Efficiency and Utility Demand-Side Management Programs
Dynamic Pricing: Past, Present, and Future
Measurement and Verification Principles for Behavior-Based Efficiency Programs
Bringing Demand-Side Management to the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
PG&E's No-Residential Enrollment Forecast
Evaluation of Baltimore Gas and Electric Company’s Smart Energy Pricing Program
Dynamic Pricing - The Top 10 Myths
Drivers of Demand Response Adoption: Past, Present, and Future
Demand Response Review
The Benefits of Smart Meters
Gas Demand Response (external link)
Consumers Energy’s Personal Power Plan Pilot
Assessing Ontatio's Regulated Price Plan: A White Paper
Shareholder Incentives: Ratemaking Mechanisms for Sustainable Energy Efficiency Programs
Economic Evaluation of Alternative Demand Response Compensation Options
Unlocking the €53 Billion Savings from Smart Meters in the EU: how increasing the adoption of dynamic tariffs could make or break the EU's smart grid investment
Household Response to Dynamic Pricing of Electricity – A Survey of 15 Experiments
An Introduction to Electricity Grid Infrastructure: System Complexity in a Rapidly Changing Industry
The Case for Dynamic Pricing
Demand Response & Energy Efficiency: The Long View
Marginal Cost Analysis in Evolving Power Markets: The Foundation of Innovative Pricing, Energy Efficiency Programs, and Net Metering Rates
Optimal Energy Efficiency Policies and Regulatory Demand-Side Management Tests: How Well Do They Match?
On Dynamic Prices: A Clash of Beliefs?
The Geography of Demand Response
Divestiture policy and operating efficiency in U.S. electric power distribution
The Impact of Dynamic Pricing on Low Income Customers
Modeling the Enrollment Forecasts for PG&E ’s Non-Residential DR Programs, 2010 - 2020
Is the smart grid going to fare better in competitive markets?
Fostering Economic Demand Response in the Midwest ISO
Smart Power: Climate Change, the Smart Grid, and the Future of Electric Utilities
Demand Response in the Midwest ISO: An Evaluation of Wholesale Market Design
Rethinking Prices
The impact of informational feedback on energy consumption - A survey of the experimental evidence
Impact Evaluation of NU's Plan-It Wise Energy Program
Dynamic Pricing: Potential Wholesale Market Benefits in New York State
Unlocking the €53 Billion Savings from Smart Meters in the EU
Lessons from Demand Response: Trials and Potential Savings for the EU
Piloting the Smart Grid
A National Assessment of Demand Response Potential
Sizing up the Smart Grid
Moving Toward Utility-Scale Deployment of Dynamic Pricing in Mass Markets
Return of the Energy Services Model: How Energy Efficiency, Climate Change, and Smart Grid Will Transform American Utilities
BGE's Smart Energy Pricing Pilot Summer 2008 Impact Evaluation
How Green is the Smart Grid?
The Power of Dynamic Pricing
Assessment of Achievable Potential for Energy Efficiency and Demand Response in the U.S. (2010-2030)
Experimental Design Considerations in Evaluating the Smart Grid
Household Response to Dynamic Pricing: A Survey of Seventeen Pricing Experiments
Integrating Dynamic Pricing and Inclining Block Rates
Inclining Toward Efficiency (download from publisher)
Demand-Side Bidding in Wholesale Electricity Markets
Will Smart Grid Promote Smart Customer Decisions?
Is Dynamic Pricing In Our Future
A National Perspective On Demand Response
Avoiding Load Shedding by Smart Metering and Pricing
Quantifying the Benefits Of Dynamic Pricing In the Mass Market
Mandating Demand Response
Rediscovering the Demand-Side of the Equation
Rethinking Rate Design
The Power of Five Percent: How Dynamic Pricing Can Save $35 Billion in Electricity Costs
California's Next Generation of Load Management Standards
Demand Response and Electricity Market Efficiency
Breaking Out of the Bubble: Using Demand Response to Mitigate Rate Shocks
From Smart Metering to Smart Pricing
Valuing Demand-Response Benefits in Eastern PJM
Dynamic Pricing as a Tool to Mitigate Rate Increases
Using Dynamic Pricing to Strengthen Your AMI Business Cases
Cost-Benefit Analysis of Smart Metering and Smart Pricing
Demand Response and the Role of Regional Transmission Operators
2050: A Pricing Oddyssey
Demand Response and Advanced Metering
Toward a New Paradigm for Valuing Demand Response
Quantifying Customer Response to Dynamic Pricing
California pricing experiment yields new insights on customer behavior
Preventing Electrical Shocks: What Ontario—And Other Provinces—Should Learn About Smart Metering